Last week, I visited KIPP Infinity Middle School, my first day-long visit to a charter school. I picked the school because I was told that KIPP Infinity, which is located opposite the M.T.A.’s Manhattanville bus depot on 133^{rd} Street in Harlem, had solved one of the thorniest problems dogging charter schools—high turnover among teachers.

One of many criticisms leveled at charter schools, most of which are not unionized, is that teachers suffer burnout because of the tough workloads. Indeed, most charter schools keep much longer hours than do traditional public schools. KIPP-affiliated schools, for example, typically start at 7:30 and don’t end until 5 p.m., at which point teachers still need to grade homework and finish preparing for the following day. Saturday school adds another half-day to the work week. And charter schools, typically, have a longer school year with some mandatory summer classes.

Joseph Negron, the founding principal of KIPP Infinity, which opened its doors in 2005, addressed the burnout problem head on. Negron, who recently resigned as principal to return to teaching–also at KIPP Infinity– shortened the school day by an hour, moving dismissal to 4 p.m from 5 p.m. He juggled the Saturday schedule so teachers would only have to teach three or four Saturdays per semester. And he allowed teachers to come in late one morning per week. “The most important thing is hiring and retaining great staff,” says Negron.

On the day of my visit, I arrive at 7:25, in time for morning meeting in the school auditorium, and am met by Peter Croncota, the director of operations, who hands me a schedule of classes and invites me to drop in on any class I wish to see. I begin with Negron’s fifth grade computation class—all fifth graders get two periods of math each day, one to bolster their computation skills and the other to work on problem-solving. There are 40 students in each computation class—by far the largest class at KIPP Infinity.

The class is starting to study estimation. Negron writes a problem on the board: 289 + 433=

“Raise your hand if you have the actual answer,” says Negron. “Now in unison.”

Most of the class calls out loudly: 722

Negron then asks the class to estimate the answer by rounding each number to the nearest 100. Then to the nearest ten. One child offers: 290 plus 440.

Negron puts both numbers on the board. “Which number is more accurate? Point to the one you think is more accurate.”

A few hands point to 440. Most kids point to 290.

He gives the students a more complicated estimation problem to work out on their own. After walking around the room for a few minutes as the students work silently, Negron says: “Brandon just asked me a brilliant question. Brandon tell us your question.”

“Since the two numbers are in the thousands, can we round to the nearest thousand?” asks the boy.

Negron pauses. “You *totally* can,” says Negron, bouncing on the balls of his feet. “DONT be a robot. Everyone do a robot.”

The entire class moves its arms in jerky motions. Giggles break the silence.

“Just ‘cause I had 10s and 100s in the earlier problem, if you have a number that goes out to the thousands, check out how easy that is. *BAM:* 2000, *BAM*: 5,000. That’s the point of estimating.

CLAP CLAP, clap, clap, clap. Negron beats out a rhythm.

CLAP CLAP, clap, clap clap, responds the class.

“I try to get them through the most passive parts of the lesson,” explains Negron who uses a whole repertoire of clapping and chanting rituals in his class.

“Research shows that kids’ attention span is their age plus two; in fifth grade that’s 12 minutes. But you have a 65 minute class.”

Negron once had every teacher follow the schedule of a child from the time he woke up at home until he left the school in the late afternoon. It was “much harder” being a kid and sitting through a typical KIPP day than the teachers had thought, explains Negron. The upshot was more time for movement, socializing and more frequent bathroom breaks.

Back in his computation class, virtually every student appears to be on task. A dozen hands pop up every time Negron asks a question. “Sit up,” Negron admonishes one child when he starts to slouch.

Only one boy sits hunched over, his head bowed, not participating. He doesn’t respond to questions. He doesn’t clap.

Negron slips him a note: “Is everything o.k.?”

The boy snaps his pencil in two.

“I am super frustrated Manuel*,” Negron finally says to the boy in front of the class. “You are too old for this. I’m just being honest.

“You’re going to choose not to be part of this team and family? Do me a favor, go outside. Take off your KIPP shirt. ‘Cause if you’re not going to be part of KIPP… How dare you come in here and wear a KIPP shirt and not act like a KIPPster. I got people in here who haven’t earned their shirts yet, who act more like a KIPPSter.”

At KIPP there is no tolerance for defiance. Students attend summer classes to learn the rules, which include—sitting up straight, responding politely to both teachers and students, handing homework in promptly. KIPP uses a paycheck system to reward and punish students. To earn privileges, including the right to wear a shirt with the KIPP logo as well as year-end trips to New England and Utah, kids need to maintain a $40 average in their paycheck accounts; each student starts the week with $70 in his paycheck. Small infractions, like calling out when it’s not your turn, get deductions of $3. Missing homework gets bigger deductions. Manuel’s act of rebellion, I later learn, zeroed out his account for the week.

I wander down the hall and drop in on a writing class taught by Frances Olajide, a three-year KIPP Infinity veteran. Unlike the rows of desks in Negron’s classroom, the desks in Olajide’s class are arranged in a “U”, around a navy rug. After giving students a few minutes to write in their journals, Olajide asks the class to sit on the rug and to look at images of sunflowers, which she projects on her white board; the sunflower photos are meant to serve as an inspiration for a creative writing assignment. “We move to the mat silently so we can do it quickly,” says Olajide softly, adding: “The most successful people in the world sit in the front where they can see and participate.”

Olajide is an African-American woman dressed this day in a trim black skirt and fucsia sweater. There is no clapping or chanting in Olajide’s class. But the class of 27-or-so students do as they are told. Later, when one boy has trouble starting a writing assignment, Olajide prods him gently: “Try to write just two sentences.”

In the eighth grade hall, Jeff Li and Gerard Griffith, share a classroom with a basketball hoop in one corner. Li, who is Asian and served as co-principal of KIPP AMP, a charter school in Brooklyn, is teaching math. At the end of class, he gives his students a few minutes to shoot hoops.

After math, Griffith, who is also a KIPP Infinity veteran and African American, begins a history lesson, starting with key vocabulary words and phrases. The class discusses civil disobedience, desegregation, popular sovereignty.

Eventually they get to “secession”.

Griffith loads a Youtube video onto the whiteboard. The screen shows the rapper and professional wrestler R. Truth (aka Ron Killings) wearing a grey confederate uniform, wielding a sword and marching down one aisle of a crowded arena. Inside the ring are a wrestler and Vince McMahon, CEO of World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE).

“I did my homework,” declares the rapper. “I be in Richmond, Virginia, the capital of the confederacy. This is where Jefferson Davis and Robert E. Lee and a bunch of other inbred rednecks just like you…”

The on-screen crowd boos loudly. The KIPP kids chuckle.

“Nothing good ever came out of the *South*,” continues R. Truth adding emphasis to key words. “The Confederacy, they did have one good idea: *Secession*. The confederacy *seceded* from the US. So tonight R. Truth is *seceding* from the WWE universe.”

“What’s ironic about the uniform that R. Truth is wearing,” Griffith asks his class.

No one responds.

“You can say it,” encourages Griffith.

“Because he’s black, and that’s a confederate uniform,” calls out one student.

R. Truth’s performance will not be his last on WWE. Nor are the KIPP Infinity students likely to forget the definition of secession.

The teaching styles of KIPP Infinity teachers are as diverse as the faculty itself. “We want to make sure that as much as possible that the teachers reflect the background of our kids,” says Negron. Virtually all KIPP Infinity students are black and Latino. About 90 percent are poor enough to be eligible for free or reduced-price lunch.

The vast majority of teachers hired at KIPP Infinity already have several years experience under their belts. Once they get here, few of them leave. The turnover rate for teachers with fewer than five years of experience was just 14 percent in 2009/10 school year, the last year for which statistics are available, down from 27 percent two years earlier. A glance through an old yearbook shows that many of the current teachers also appeared in the 2009 edition. But many have taken on new duties.

Indeed, in addition to holding on to its teachers, KIPP Infinity seems to have tackled another key management challenge—succession planning. When Negron decided to return to his first love—teaching–he identified Allison Willis Holley, a long-time non-fiction studies teacher at the school to succeed him.

“It’s not really a change at all,” says one long-time KIPP parent. “We’ve known Ms. Holley forever.”

Holley has continued to tweak the teacher schedule, still with a view to avoiding teacher burnout. She has extended the school day to 5 p.m. for kids who need extra help with reading, and is introducing a new reading enrichment program that she hopes will bolster literacy as the school where math scores consistently outpace student performance on ELA. In exchange, she has eliminated Saturday school entirely.

In 2011, 41 percent of KIPP Infinity students received 3s or 4s, the top two scores, in the state English tests while close to 84 percent scored 3s and 4s in math. Roughly 10 percent of KIPP students are held back each year.

I wondered what would happen to a defiant child like Manuel, who is new at the school this year and who is having trouble adapting.

Negron assures me that Manuel is back on track. He spent the rest of the day “cooling off”, but is now back in class. Negron asked one of the other teachers to talk to Manuel who, the teachers believe, is suffering from separation anxiety. Negron and the boy then had a discussion about what they both wish they had done differently. “He said he wished he hadn’t thrown his KIPP t-shirt,” says Negron. “I told him I wished I hadn’t raised my voice.”

But Negron also tells me that he had to draw a line. “I had to make a decision,” he explains. “Every kid is seeing him not participate.”

After my first day at KIPP, the one conclusion I could draw was that KIPP Inifinity non-participation is not an option.

*I have changed the name of the student to protect his identity.

*Please stay tuned for an upcoming conversation with a KIPP Infinity parent on KIPP curriculum, discipline and raising kids in Harlem. *

Pingback: Remainders: Many schools slipped in their progress reports | GothamSchools

Negron’s public humiliation of a student -standard operating procedure at Skinner Boxes like KIPP- is reprehensible, demonstrating why these boot camps have the high student attrition rates they do.. No wonder students call the place “Kids in Prison Program.”

Are we to think that shaming students in front of their peers constitutes a “laboratory of innovation,” and is a model for schools elsewhere, or is it instead part of the training and behavior modification that poor and minority children are to receive, in order to prepare them for the authoritarian workplaces they are being groomed to work passively and unquestioningly in?

You write that this KIPP has “solved” the problem of high turnover among teachers. What is the attrition rate of teachers at the school, and what is the source of your data? Also what is the student attrition rate at the school? thanks,

Leonie–Thanks for your question. Regarding teacher turnover: According to the school’s report card on the nysed.gov website, the turnover rate for teachers with less than 5 years of experience was 14% in the 2009/2010 school year, down from 27% two years earlier. For teachers with more than 5 years experience turnover was 21% for both those years. Of course, when you click on the schools report card site, nysed.gov posts the following disclaimer “The site you are about to visit may not be under the jurisdiction of the New York City Department of Education and thus the Department may not be responsible for its content.” However, during my random walk through the school, I spoke to about a dozen teachers–one-third of the teaching force–and only one of those had less than three years at the school.

The question of student attrition is trickier. If you look at the same report card, the class sizes drop a little every year. In 2009/2010, the lowest drop was between Grade 6 and 7 of just over 3%; the highest drop was between Grade 9 and 10 of almost 20%.

Please stay tuned for more on KIPP in future posts

CORRECTION: I made an error in the student enrollment data, in answer to Leonie’s question. The changes between grade levels from 2008/2009 school year to the 2009/2010 school year are actually much smaller than I had originally indicated. For example, the fifth grade class in 2008/2009 has 81 students, but the sixth grade class in 2009/2010 (presumably the same class a year later) has 79 students–about a six percent drop. By contrast, the eighth grade class of 2008/2009 has 57 students, while the next year’s ninth grade class has 61 students, i.e. an increase of about 7 percent. This data alone isn’t enough to draw conclusions about student attrition. We’d need to know how many new students are admitted each year. How many old students leave etc.

Wow, this article is nice, my younger sister is analyzing these things, thus I

am going to tell her.

I am a KIPP parent and I would like to know if there is any news for the current year, 2014-2015 for students coming in from KIPP elementary? I have a few problems with KIPP schools as a whole. I also have a child that graduated from KIPP college Prep.